China Holds Drills With Both India and Pakistan

Posted: November 21, 2014 in War Is The New Economy

SEE ALSO:  China Buying Into India’s Largest e-Payment System……Yet India Increases Military Spending 12% To Counter ‘China Threat’

SEE ALSO:  U.S. and Russia Sell Arms to Both Sides of India Pakistan Tension

India, China to Hold Counter-Terror Drill
Deepak Dobhal 
November 13, 2014

Hundreds of Indian and Chinese soldiers met in a tense standoff on their disputed border just two months ago. This Sunday, the two countries will carry out counterterrorism exercises — together.The decision to go ahead with joint maneuvers offers insight into the complexity of Sino-Indian relations and is an indication the nations are willing to manage their differences and engage in mutually-beneficial plans, despite serious disputes.

Since both India and China have identified terrorism as a major threat, it suits their national security interests to participate in such a exercise, according to Srikanth Kondapalli, Honorary Fellow at the Institute of Chinese Studies, Delhi.

China considers the threat from radical Islam to be one of its main security concerns, especially in Xinjiang province, which has been rocked in recent years by deadly attacks. Chinese authorities also are alarmed by reports of Chinese fighters joining the ranks of the extremist Islamic State, which revives longstanding fears. As far back as 2004, then President Hu Jintao identified “separatism, extremism and terrorism” as “three evil forces” that need to be dealt with.

India has been facing Islamist militancy even longer, suffering decades of extremist actions. It now considers cross-border terrorism its main national security challenge.

The exact details of the 10-day exercise, to be held in Pune in western India, are not public. But both sides will tackle insurgency and terrorism scenarios, according to India’s defense ministry.

Past experience shows they will likely identify a target such as a terrorist hold-up and try to neutralize the situation, said retired Lieutenant General  Vasantha R. Raghavan, president of India-based think tank, Center for Security Analysis. He added that the two sides will then exchange notes on how they approached the problem and how it worked.

A spokesman for India’s defense ministry said such scenarios will help both sides in “developing joint strategies of conducting operations in a counter terrorism environment.”

The exercise is planned at the company level, which means about 120 troops from each side will participate. Some observers believe that indicates a very low-level engagement and interaction between the two sides will be limited.

Raghvan concedes the scope of the drill is modest compared to exercises India conducts with the U.S. He insisted, though, that “working with the military of a totally different kind is a significant military gain.”

Both sides are unwilling to raise the size and complexity of the exercises because of their historically suspicious relationship. India and China went to war in 1962 over their disputed frontier and other issues.

This is the fourth joint training exercise between the armies of the two countries. The first was held in 2007. India called it off in 2009 when China refused to issue a visa to an Indian general, part of continuing unease in the relationship.

The exercise resumed in 2013 after a gap of five years.

India’s insecurity

William Antholis, author of “Inside Out India and China: Local Politics Go Global,” said India wants better economic ties with China to achieve its developmental goals. But, he added, India remains suspicious of Chinese intentions.

Chinese President Xi Jinping’s visit to India in September showed many Indians their suspicions were well-founded.

On the day of his arrival, Xi said that “China-India relations have become one of the most dynamic and promising bilateral relations in the 21st century” in an editorial published in the Indian newspaper “The Hindu.” But even as he was warming up to Indian leaders and promising a robust economic partnership, hundreds of Chinese soldiers crossed the Line of Actual Control, the de-facto border between the two countries. India’s media frantically reported a Chinese incursion.

One month later, India appeared to retaliate, announcing it will build some 1,800 kilometers of road in the contested region along the border.

China reacted sharply to India’s plans and warned that it will further complicate the boundary problem.

According to retired Lieutenant General Raghavan, who has commanded troops along the Line of Actual Control, the project was long overdue as India lags far behind China in border infrastructure. He said in some places Indian soldiers can take days to reach the Line of Actual Control. Without improvement, he said, India could seem helpless in the face of a Chinese incursion.

Both countries have moved forward in a number of areas following the 1988 decision to separate the boundary issue from the rest of the relationship. But the recent standoff was a stark reminder the boundary dispute needs settling, according to Shivshankar Menon, former National Security Adviser of India.

Speaking at the Brookings Institution, a Washington, D.C.-based think tank, Menon said Chinese incursions along the unmarked Line of Actual Control do not constitute a military threat. But he added, it is a political issue with potential to cloud the rest of the relationship.

China wary of regional encirclement

China is apprehensive of India’s growing ties with other Asia-Pacific countries as well as the U.S.

In September, India and the US raised the issue of the South China Sea, where China is locked in a territorial dispute with many Southeast Asian countries, in a joint statement during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to the U.S. The statement “called on all parties to avoid the use, or threat of use, of force in advancing their claims” in South China Sea.

Antholis, who interviewed extensively in China and India for his book, said “many in China are suspicious that greater U.S.-India cooperation is meant to counterbalance China.”

India’s signing of a deal last month with Vietnam to cooperate on oil and gas exploration in the contested South China Sea appears to have made matters worse.

The deal with Vietnam “only confirms the view that India is working with those who are trying to encircle and constrain China,” said Antholis.

Indian analysts dispute the notion that India aims to become a balancing force in Asia.

According to Shivshankar Menon, who also has served as India’s foreign secretary, India just wants a security architecture that is inclusive and addresses India’s concerns.

India has a strong interest in the South China Sea as 55 percent of its trade passes through those waters. Srikanth Kondapalli said, “there is no guarantee that China is willing to promise a secure passage for the Indian trade.”

Future relationship

Despite the tensions, most analysts believe there are compelling reasons India and China will avoid crisis.

They argue China knows it is in its best interest to project a peaceful image as it strides forward on the world stage. As for India, the analysts say a peaceful environment is critical if it is to realize its development goals. Also, they point out that both are nuclear powers, a strong deterrent to engaging in conflict.

Going forward, experts believe China and India will place a strong emphasis on economic relations; they will manage the border dispute, even though they’re unlikely to solve it. Menon said future generations may well have to deal with an issue that seems too complicated to be tackled now.

Until then, activities like the upcoming joint exercises are a way to navigate troubled relations and build some trust.



Chinese troops training Pak Army near India-Pakistan border

NEW DELHI: Chinese troops have been spotted imparting arms training to Pakistan Army on Pakistani forward locations on the border opposite the Rajouri sector in Jammu & Kashmir, the Border Security Force (BSF) has told the National Security Advisor (NSA) Ajit Doval in a secret report. BSF has also warned that Pakistan Army is taking charge of key Pakistani border posts from the Pakistani Rangers, beefing up manpower and posting snipers to target Indian troops.

This comes as a major concern for India after the heightened tension on the border that led to repeated firing from both sides in October. The BSF has informed the NSA that in one such firing incident on October 6, five Pakistani soldiers were killed after strong retaliatory firing from the Indian side. The input of Chinese presence on Pakistani Forward locations, albeit only for Weapon handling Training, is bound to raise tensions between India and China as well, a Intelligence official said.

The BSF report, sent to the NSA, Intelligence Bureau Chief and the Home Secretary, says it has been learnt that Chinese troops have been seen in some of the Pakistani Forward locations of the 3rd and 4th Pakistan-Occupied-Kashmir Brigades opposite India’s Rajouri sector and they are imparting weapon handling training to Pakistani troops.

BSF has said that the situation on the International Border in Jammu remains tense but Pakistani civilians who had shifted from the border areas due to cross-border firing have returned to their villages. In the second week of October, units of Pakistani Army have also moved to Pakistani forward locations opposite the Rajouri Sector to beef up manpower strength of troops on the border, the BSF has said.

The BSF has also warned that intercepted conversations across the border reveal that Pakistani Rangers and Pakistani Army will be deploying commandoes and snipers on some of their border posts on both the International Border and the Line of Control to carry out targeted attacks on forces on the Indian side.

The Centre has been warned that there is a large presence of terrorists on forward locations in the Sialkot area waiting to infiltrate into India ahead of the assembly elections in the state. BSF has warned that terrorists of Lashkar-e-Toiba, Jaish-e-Mohammad and Hizbul Mujahedeen have stepped up their activities in South Kashmir in districts of Anantnag, Shopian and Pulawama and there could be attacks on security forces convoys and political party workers in the upcoming J&K elections in these areas. It has been mentioned that the situation in J&K hence remains sensitive but under control of security forces.

The BSF report has also cited a input sent out by the Headquarter Pakistani Rangers to all its Wings saying that the Tahreek–E-Taliban (TTP) commander Mohammad Abdul Wali has put together 22 terrorist teams of 6 men each to target security forces and locals in Pakistan. The TTP has claimed responsibility for the recent attack on the Wagah border in which over 60 Pakistanis were killed and on Thursday had also released a photograph of the suicide bomber.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s